Placement Agency vs. Home Care Agency: Key Differences
November 14, 2026 · By Kristy Park
A senior care placement agency helps you find care, while a home care agency provides the care. A placement or referral service matches you with communities or providers and is usually paid by them. A home care agency employs, screens, schedules, and supervises the caregivers who come to your parent's home.
Both can be useful. The right choice depends on whether you are still deciding what kind of care your parent needs or already know you want help at home. Here is how each one works and what to ask so you can decide with confidence.
What a senior care placement agency does
A senior care placement agency, sometimes called a senior care referral service, acts as a matchmaker. You describe your parent's needs, budget, and location. The advisor then suggests options, which may include assisted living communities, memory care communities, and sometimes home care agencies.
Many of these services are free to families. They are commonly paid a referral fee by the community or provider you choose. That arrangement is not wrong in itself, but it is worth understanding, because it can shape which options you hear about. A referral service may only recommend providers it has an agreement with.
Placement agencies are often most helpful when:
- You are unsure whether your parent should stay home or move to a community
- You want to compare several assisted living or memory care communities quickly
- You are new to the area or arranging care from out of town
What a placement agency typically does not do is provide the caregiver, supervise the care, or step in when a shift needs to be covered. Once the match is made, your ongoing relationship is with the provider.
What a home care agency does
A home care agency sends trained caregivers into your parent's home and stays responsible for that care over time. A non-medical home care agency helps with daily life, such as personal care like bathing, dressing, and toileting, companionship and help around the house, meals, transportation, and medication reminders.
When you hire a home care agency directly, the agency handles:
- Recruiting and screening caregivers
- Employing them, including payroll and related responsibilities
- Building a schedule and finding a replacement if a caregiver is sick
- Supervising care and adjusting it as needs change
- Being the single point of contact when something comes up
In Florida, home care agencies are licensed by the Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA). Some also hold outside accreditation, which means an independent organization has reviewed how they operate.
A third model you may run into in Florida: nurse registries
Florida also licenses nurse registries. These connect families with caregivers who generally work as independent contractors rather than employees of the registry. That can affect who handles scheduling, backup coverage, supervision, and employer responsibilities. If a provider describes itself as a registry, ask exactly what it does and does not take responsibility for. It is a different arrangement from an agency that employs its caregivers.
The key differences side by side
Who provides the care
A placement agency refers you elsewhere. A home care agency provides the caregiver.
Who pays them
Placement agencies are often paid by the communities or providers they refer to. Home care agencies are paid by the family or by insurance for the hours of care delivered.
Who you call when something goes wrong
With a placement agency, once your parent moves in or care starts, you usually call the provider, not the advisor. With a home care agency, you call the agency, and it is responsible for fixing the problem.
Range of options
A placement agency can show you several types of care at once. A home care agency focuses on care at home, so it is the better fit once you know staying home is the goal.
Questions to ask a placement or referral service
- How are you paid, and by whom?
- Do you only recommend providers you have agreements with?
- Have you personally visited the communities or met with the agencies you suggest?
- Will you share my information with multiple providers? Can I control who contacts me?
- Do you include in-home care as an option, or mostly communities?
A good advisor will answer these openly. If you start getting calls from many providers you never asked to hear from, that tells you something about how the service works.
Questions to ask when hiring a home care agency directly
- Are you licensed by AHCA? Are you accredited by any outside organization?
- Are caregivers your employees or independent contractors?
- How do you screen caregivers? What background checks do you run?
- What happens if a caregiver calls out? How quickly do you find a replacement?
- Who answers the phone after hours and on weekends?
- What is your hourly rate, and is there a minimum shift length?
- How do you bill overnight or 24-hour care?
- What payment sources do you accept?
- How do you match caregivers to clients, and can we request a change?
Ask these out loud and listen for specific answers. Vague replies on backup coverage or after-hours support are worth noting, since those are the moments families need help most.
What home care costs
Rates vary by agency and by the level of care. At Supporting Independence, non-medical home care costs $28 to $32 an hour, with a 4-hour minimum per visit. Overnight and 24-hour care are billed at the same hourly rate, not a flat daily or nightly rate. We accept private pay and long-term care insurance.
Some families look into Medicaid or VA benefits to help pay for care. Eligibility and coverage rules vary, so check directly with those programs or a qualified professional. Supporting Independence does not accept Medicaid or VA benefits; we work with private pay and long-term care insurance only.
If your parent has a long-term care insurance policy, call the insurer to ask what the policy covers, whether there is a waiting period, and what paperwork they need from the agency.
Which should you use first?
Start with a placement or referral service if you genuinely do not know whether your parent should move or stay home, and you want help comparing communities.
Go straight to a home care agency if your parent wants to stay home and you can describe the help they need, even roughly. Signs that point toward in-home help include trouble bathing safely, skipped meals, missed appointments because driving has become hard, loneliness, or a recent hospital stay. Calling an agency directly also lets you ask detailed questions, meet the people responsible for care, and set up a schedule without a go-between.
Either way, talk with your parent's doctor about any change in health, memory, or mobility. Home care caregivers can help with daily living and can observe and report changes, but they do not replace medical care. If your parent has a sudden change, a fall with injury, or trouble breathing, call 911.
When to call us
If your parent lives in Orange or Seminole County and you are leaning toward help at home, it may make sense to call Supporting Independence at (407) 434-0766. A real person answers, and you can ask any of the questions above. You can also read more about our personal care services or send us a message.
Home care where you live
Supporting Independence provides in-home care across Orange and Seminole County: Maitland, Winter Park, Altamonte Springs, Orlando, Longwood, Casselberry, Oviedo, Sanford. Call (407) 434-0766 for a free in-home consultation.